|
|
|
Li v. Liu (Case of Infringement against the Right of Authorship and the Right Right to Network Dissemination of Information)
|
|
琘琘禗糂琘琘獻甡珇竝舦獺呼蹈肚冀舦
|
|
猭腳ま靡絏
|
- Legal document
Judgment
- Judgment date
11-27-2023
- Procedural status
Trial at First Instance
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Beijing Internet Court A Civil Judgment of Li v. Liu (Case of Infringement against the Right of Authorship and the Right Right to Network Dissemination of Information) | | 琘琘禗糂琘琘獻甡珇竝舦獺呼蹈肚冀舦ㄊが羛呼猭皘チㄆ∕ |
| (2023) Jing 0491 Min Chu No. 11279 (2023) | | (2023)ㄊ0491チ11279腹 |
| Plaintiff: LI, male | | 琘琘 |
| Agent ad litem 1: Sun Yan, lawyer at Beijing Tian Yuan Law Firm | | 〆Λ禗砠瞶甝ㄊカぱじ畍ㄆ叭┮畍 |
| Agent ad litem 2: Li Yufan, lawyer at Beijing Tian Yuan Law Firm | | 〆Λ禗砠瞶ㄊカぱじ畍ㄆ叭┮畍 |
| Defendant: LIU, female | | 砆糂琘琘 |
| The case of LI (the plaintiff) v. LIU (the defendant) over infringement of the right of authorship and the right of dissemination on the information network was filed by the Court on May 25, 2023. A collegial panel was formed in accordance with the law, with ordinary procedures being applied. After a pre-trial meeting, a public hearing was held on August 24, 2023. The plaintiff LI and his agents Sun Yan and Li Yufan, and the defendant LIU attended the trial via the e-litigation platform of the Court. The case has now been concluded. | | 琘琘籔砆糂琘琘獻甡珇竝舦獺呼蹈肚冀舦セ皘20235る25らミㄌ猭舱Θ某畑続ノ炊硄祘竒畑玡穦某20238る24らそ秨秨畑秈︽糵瞶琘琘のㄤ〆Λ禗砠瞶甝砆糂琘琘硄筁セ皘筿禗砠キ絬把禗砠セ瞷糵瞶沧挡 |
| The plaintiff LI requested that: 1. The defendant issue a public statement on the baijiahao account involved to apologize to the plaintiff and eliminate the impact of the infringement; 2. The defendant compensate 5,000 yuan for the plaintiff's economic losses. Facts and cause of case: On February 24, 2023, the plaintiff generated the picture involved by inputting prompt words in Stable Diffusion, an open source software, and then published the picture on Little Red Book, a social media platform, under the title ¨Spring Breeze Brings Tenderness.〃 Later, the plaintiff found that the picture was used in an article titled ¨Love in March, in the Peach Blossoms,〃 which was published by the defendant under the baijiahao account ¨******〃 on March 2, 2023. The defendant had used the picture without the plaintiff's permission and even removed the plaintiff's watermark on Little Red Book, causing viewers to believe that the defendant was the author of the picture. The defendant's behavior seriously violated the plaintiff's right of authorship and of dissemination on the information network. The defendant should compensate the plaintiff for his economic losses and make an apology to eliminate the impact. Accordingly, the plaintiff filed a lawsuit to the Court and requested the above. | | 琘琘セ皘矗禗砠叫―1.叫―砆疉κ產腹祇ガそ秨羘竭搂笵簆埃ㄤ獻舦︽倒硑Θ紇臫2.叫―砆竭纕竒蕾穕ア5000じㄆ龟籔瞶パ20232る24らㄏノ秨方硁ンStable Diffusion硄筁块矗ボ迭よΑネΘ疉瓜盢赣瓜¨琄癳ㄓ放琗〃祇ガキら祇瞷κ產腹姐腹¨и琌冻秨ら〃20233る2ら祇ガる稲薄ゅ彻赣ゅ彻皌瓜ㄏノ疉瓜砆ゼ莉眔砛篒キ竝ㄏ眔闽ノめ粇粄砆赣珇腨獻デㄉΤ竝舦の獺呼蹈肚冀舦砆莱讽竭纕竒蕾穕ア秈︽竭搂笵簆埃紇臫侯疭ㄌ猭猭皘矗癬禗砠叫―猭皘┮叫 |
| The defendant LIU argued that: 1. The defendant searched the Internet and obtained the picture involved and used it as an illustration for his original poem ¨Love in March, in the Peach Blossoms.〃 The defendant cannot provide the specific source of the picture, nor can he explain the watermark on it. It is uncertain whether the plaintiff has the right to the picture involved; 2. The content published by the defendant is mainly about the original poem, not the picture involved. The picture is not for commercial use, so the defendant has no intention of infringement; 3. If the Court determines that the defendant's behavior constitutes infringement, the defendant will apologize to the plaintiff. However, the amount of economic compensation claimed by the plaintiff is too high; the market price of AI-generated images is rather low. The defendant is seriously ill and unable to pay the compensation. Accordingly, the defendant requested the Court to consider the actual situation while making a judgment. | | 砆糂琘琘臛嘿砆硄筁呼蹈浪莉疉瓜ノ承钢簈る稲薄皌瓜疉瓜ㄣ砰ㄓ方礚猭矗ㄑョ礚猭弧疉酚薄猵ぃ絋﹚琌ㄉΤ疉瓜舦砆┮祇ガ璶ず甧承钢ゅτ獶疉瓜⊿Τ坝穨ノ硚ぃㄣΤ獻舦珿種狦猭皘粄﹚疉︽篶Θ獻舦砆腀種竭搂笵簆琌眎竒蕾竭纕计肂筁蔼AIネΘ瓜カ初基砆ō眞痜礚竭纕侯叫―猭皘σ納龟悔薄猵秈︽∕ |
| The parties submitted evidence based on their statements, and the Court organized the parties to conduct evidence exchange and cross-examination. The Court confirmed the evidence that the parties had no objection to and corroborated it in the file. Regarding the facts of the case, the Court found that: | | 讽ㄆ瞅露禗砠叫―ㄌ猭矗ユ靡沮セ皘舱麓讽ㄆ秈︽靡沮ユ传㎝借靡癸讽ㄆ礚钵某靡沮セ皘ぉ絋粄︴靡癸ンㄆ龟セ皘粄﹚ |
| On February 26, 2023, the plaintiff posted the picture involved (see Figure 6) on his Little Red Book account ¨****〃 (Little Red Book ID: ******), and the title of the post was ¨Spring Breeze Brings Tenderness.〃 Apart from the picture involved, the post included five other pictures,with hashtags #AI#[topic]# #AIillustration#AIpainting#photo#girl#photography#spring#beauty. Through investigation, it is found that the plaintiff is able to log in to the account and check the picture involved by obtaining a verification code through his mobile phone. | | 20232る26ら盢疉瓜(ǎ瓜6)祇ガㄤ姐腹¨赋〃(腹⊙⊙⊙⊙⊙)い祇ガず甧夹肈¨琄癳ㄓ放琗〃赣夹肈埃疉瓜ョㄤ5眎瓜夹帽¨#AI#[杠肈]# #AI础礶 #AI酶礶 #糶痷 #ぶ #尼紇 #琄ぱ #〃竒猭皘舱麓蛮よ吧喷硄筁も诀腹絏莉喷靡絏よΑ祅魁赣姐腹琩疉瓜祇ガ薄猵 |
| The plaintiff claimed that the picture was generated via Stable Diffusion on February 24, 2023. He submitted a video that demonstrates the process of generating the picture involved. The steps are as follows: | | 眎赣瓜╰ㄤ20232る24ら硄筁硁ンStable DiffusionネΘㄤ矗ユ瞷疉瓜ネΘ筁祘跌繵ㄣ砰巨˙艼 |
| 1. Go to bilibili.com, search for the user ¨腑 aaaki〃, open the video titled ¨[AI Art Generator] Stable Diffusion whole package v4.2 released! Accelerated, extract and ready-to-use, no more out of memory, paint with AI in 3 mins...〃, click the link under the video https://pan.baidu.com/s/1sVmVqA2CGUsZwyRdjoA5Vg and download the zip file ¨sd-webui-aki-V4.2.7z.〃 Unzip it and open the file ¨A User Agreement.txt〃, which says: ¨This package is only used for AIGC learning. It is based on the open s- ource program Stable Diffusion Webui on Github and provides an operating environment for the algorithm. Using this package means that you have read and agree to the following user agreement: You shall not carry out behaviors including but not limited to the following, nor shall you facilitate any behavior that violates laws and regulations: Opposing the basic principles stipulated in the Constitution; Endangering national s- ecurity, leaking state secrets, subverting state power, or undermining national unity; Damaging national honor and interests; Inciting ethnic hatred and ethnic discrimination, and undermining ethnic unity; Undermining national religious policies, and promoting cults and feudal superstitions; Spreading rumors, disrupting social order, and undermini- ng social stability; Spreading information on obscenity, pornography, gambling, violenc- e, murder, terror or instigating crimes; Insulting or slandering others and infringing up on the legitimate rights and interests of others; Carrying out any behavior that violates the ˉseven base lines'; Other things prohibited by laws and administrative regulations. All consequences and responsibilities arising from any violation of laws and regulations in the generation, collection, processing, use of your data and other related matters shall be borne by you.〃 | | 1.ゴ秨bilibili呼穓ノめ¨腑aaaki〃ゴ秨夹肈¨AI酶礶Stable Diffusion俱v4.2祇ガ!穝硉秆溃ノ ň脄陪 だ灵AI酶礶〃跌繵ゴ秨跌繵よ矗ㄑ呼絃渺钡¨https://pan.baidu.com/s/1sVmVqA2CGUsZwyRdjoA5Vg〃更¨sd-webui-aki-V4.2.7z〃溃罽秆溃罽ゴ秨ゅン¨Aノめ某.txt〃陪ボ¨セ俱度ノAIGCм砃厩策膀Github秨方兜ヘStable Diffusion Webui矗ㄑ衡猭笲︽吏挂ㄏノセ俱眤綷弄種ノめ某眤ぃ眔龟琁珹ぃ︽ぃ眔ヴ笻は猭猭砏︽矗ㄑ獽は癸舅猭┮砏﹚膀セ玥甡瓣產猲臩瓣產盞腁滦瓣產現舦瘆胊瓣產参穕甡瓣產篴臕㎝痲捍笆チ壁こチ壁猍跌瘆胊チ壁刮挡瘆胊瓣產﹙毙現郸喘ǜ毙㎝癵獺床ガ亮ē耑睹穦瘆胊穦铆﹚床ガ瞉漏︹薄戒痴忌た炳┢┪毙デ竜玍癲┪节两獻甡猭舦痲龟琁ヴ笻璉¨兵┏絬〃︽Τ猭︽現猭砏窽ゎㄤず甧眤计沮玻ネΜ栋矪瞶ㄏノ单ヴ闽ㄆ兜笻は猭猭砏单薄猵τ硑Θ场挡狦の砫ヴАパ眤︽┯踞〃 |
| 2. Open ¨A launcher.exe〃, and the homepage is shown in Figure 1. Select version, and click Start. | | 2.ゴ秨¨A币笆竟.exe〃瓜1┮ボ匡拒セ翴阑龄币笆 |
| (Figure 1 omitted) | | (瓜1菠) |
| 3. Go to bilibili.com again, search for the user ¨K43〃, open the article titled ¨Stable Diffusion Art Models help you get the beautiful Asian/Chinese girl portraits〃, copy the URL ¨https: //huggingface.co/dcy/AsiaFacemix/tree/main〃 in the article and open it in the browser, download the model packages ¨AsiaFacemix-pruned-fix.safetensors〃 and ¨lora-hanfugirl-v1-5.safetensors〃. | | 3.bilibili呼穓ノめ¨K43〃ゴ秨夹肈¨Stale Diffusion暗糶龟磕家 琵酶腞ㄈ瑆い瓣ぶ钩〃ゅ彻ゅ彻い狡呼¨https://huggingface.co/dcy/AsiaFacemix/tree/main〃聅凝竟いゴ秨更家¨AsiaFacemix-pruned-fix.safetensors〃¨lora-hanfugirl-v1-5.safetensors〃 |
| Move ¨AsiaFacemix-pruned-fix.safetensors〃 to ¨models〃 – ¨Stable-diffusion〃, and change the model of the launcher (Stable-diffusion model) to ¨AsiaFacemix-pruned-fix.safetensors〃. Move ¨lora-hanfugirl-v1-5. safetensors〃 to ¨extensions〃 – ¨sd-webui-additi- onal-networks〃 – ¨models〃 – ¨lora〃, and change Model 1 in ¨Additional-Networks〃 to ¨lord-hanfugirl-v1-5.safetensors〃. | | 盢家¨AsiaFacemix-pruned-fix.safetensors〃簿笆¨models〃-¨Stable-diffusion〃ゅンЖ盢币笆竟(Stable-diffusion家)家э¨AsiaFacemix-pruned-fix.safetensors〃盢家¨lora-hanfugirl-v1-5.safetensors〃簿笆¨extensions〃-¨sd-webui-additional-networks〃-¨models〃-¨lora〃ゅンЖ盢币笆竟¨Additiona1-Networks〃い家1э¨lord-hanfugirl-v1-5.safetensors〃 |
| 4. Enter the following prompt words:¨(ultra photorealistic:1.3)extremely high quality highdetail RAW color photo,in locations,japan idol,highly detailed symmetrical attractive face,angular simmetrical face,perfectskin,skin pores,dreamy black eyes,reddish-br- own plaits hairs,uniform,long legs,thighhighs,soft focus,(film grain,vivid colors,film emulation,kodak gold portra 100, 35mm, canon50 f1.2)Lens Flare,Golden Hour,HD,Cinematic,Beautiful Dynamic Lighting〃. Enter the following negative prompt words:¨((3d,render,cg,painting,drawing,cartoon,anime,comic:1.2))bad anatomy,bad hands,text,error,missing fingers,extra digit,fewer digits,cropped,worst quality,signature,watermark,username,blurry,artist name,(longbody)bad anatomy,liquid body,malformed,mutated,badproportions, uncoordinated body,unnaturalbody,disfigured,ugly,gross proportions,mutation,disfigured,deformed,(mutation),(child:1.2)b&w,fat,extra nipples,minimalistic,nsfw,lowres,badanatomy, bad hands,text,error,missing fingers,extra digit,fewer digits,cropped,worst quality,low quality,normal quality,jpeg artifacts,signature,watermark,username,blurry,disfigured,kitsch,ugl- y,oversaturated,grain,low-res,Deformed,disfigured,poorly drawn face,mutation,mutated,extr- a limb,ugly,poorly drawn hands,missing limb,floating limbs,disconnected limbs,malformed hands,blur,out of focus,long neck,long body,ugly,disgusting,poorly drawn,childish,mutilated,mangled,old,surreal,text,b&w,monochrome,conjoined twins,multiple heads,extra legs, extra arms,meme,elongated,twisted,fingers,strabismus,heterochromia,closed eyes,blurred,watermark,wedding,group,dark skin,dark-skinned femaletattoos,nude,lowres,badanatomy, badhands,text,error,missing fingers,extra digit,fewer digits,cropped,worst quality,low quality,normal quality,jpeg artifacts,signature,watermark,username,blurry〃. Among them, ¨((3d render, CG, painting, drawing, cartoon, anime, comic: 1.2))〃 comes from the defen- dant himself, and the rest are directly copied from an online forum. | | 4.タ矗ボ迭(Prompt)块¨(ultra photorealistic:1.3)extremely high quality highdetail RAW color photoin locationsjapan idolhighly detailed symmetrical attractive faceangular simmetrical faceperfectskinskin poresdreamy black eyesreddish-brown plaits hairsuniformlong legsthighhighssoft focus(film grainvivid colorsfilm emulationkodak gold portra 10035mmcanon50 f1.2)Lens FlareGolden HourHDCinematicBeautiful Dynamic Lighting〃いゅ亩ゅ(禬笹痷酚1:3)禬蔼珇借蔼灿竊﹍瓜钩计沮矪瞶Α眒︹酚春らセ案钩蔼灿竊癸嘿癵羪俦àっ嘿羪Чブ涧ブ涧をふ冠ほ堵泊氟脚︹膢Аっ籐旦柠硁癸礘(溅瞶ネ笆︹眒溅ラ痷琠笷独╲钩100.35mmㄎ50f1.2)描繷穡独丁蔼睲筿紇腞笆篈縊は矗ボ迭(Negative Prompt)块¨((3drendercgpaintingdrawingcartoonanimecomic:1.2))bad anatomybad handstexterrormissing fingersextra digitfewer digitscroppedworst qualitysignaturewatermarkusernameblurryartist name(long body)bad anatomyliquid bodymalformedmutatedbad proportionsuncoordinated bodyunnatural bodydisfigureduglygross proportionsmutationdisfigureddeformed(mutation)(child:1.2)b&wfatextra nipplesminimalisticnsfwlowresbadanatomybad handstexterrormissing fingersextra digitfewer digitscroppedworst qualitylow qualitynormal qualityjpeg artifactssignaturewatermarkusernameblurrydisfiguredkitschuglyoversaturatedgrainlow-resDeformeddisfiguredpoorly drawn facemutationmutatedextra limbuglypoorly drawn handsmissing limbfloating limbsdisconnected limbsmalformed handsblurout of focuslong necklong bodyuglydisgustingpoorly drawnchildishmutilatedmangledoldsurrealtextb&wmonochromeconjoined twinsmultiple headsextra legsextra armsmemeelongatedtwistedfingersstrabismusheterochromiaclosed eyesblurredwatermarkweddinggroupdark skindark-skinned femaletattoosnudelowresbadanatomybadhandstexterrormissing fingersextra digitfewer digitscroppedworst qualitylow qualitynormal qualityjpeg artifactssignaturewatermarkusernameblurry〃いゅ亩ゅ((3d磋琕ㄒ酶礶磞硄笆憨憨礶1.2))罺縷秆挡篶罺縷もゅ岿粇アも计ぶ计掉芭程畉借秖帽ノめ家絢美砃產(砰)罺縷秆挡篶睪砰奉跑罺縷ゑㄒぃ秸ō砰ぃ礛ō砰反穕拎彩ゑㄒ跑反穕跑(跑)(ㄠ担1.2)堵籔フㄅ繷伐虏竡ぃ続﹜初┮だ侩瞯罺縷秆挡篶罺縷もゅ岿粇アも计ぶ计掉芭程畉借秖借秖タ盽借秖jpeg鞍紇帽ノめ家絢反甧碅玌拎筁埂㎝瞶だ侩瞯跑反甧⊿礶羪跑跑砰拎⊿礶もア砰簘疊砰耞秨砰奉も家絢ア礘蹭ō砰拎碿み礶眔ぃギ竂摧や瞒瘆窰陪ρ禬瞷龟ゅセ堵㎝フ虫︹硈砰蛮璏璍繷场籐も羥家┰пΡも弊跌钵︹超泊氟家絢盉搂刮砰瞏︹ブ涧瞏︹ブ涧┦ō籸砰だ侩瞯罺縷秆挡篶罺縷もゅ岿粇アも计ぶ计掉芭程畉借秖借秖タ盽借秖Jpeg鞍紇帽ノめ家絢ㄤいは矗ボ迭い¨((3drendercgpaintingdrawingcartoonanimecomic:1.2))〃╰ㄤ︽絪胯ㄤ┮Τは矗ボ迭А╰ㄤ钡狡琘阶韭いノめだㄉ矗ボ迭ず甧 |
| 5. Change the number of iteration steps to 33, height to 768, CFG scale to 9, random seed to 2692150200, and click the ¨Generate〃 button. The operation interface is shown in Figure 2, and the result generated is shown in Figure 3. | | 5.盢˙计э33蔼э768矗ボ迭ま旧╰计э9繦诀计贺э2692150200翴阑¨ネΘ〃龄巨瓜2┮ボネΘ挡狦瓜3┮ボ |
| (Figure 2 omitted) | | (瓜2菠) |
| (Figure 3 omitted) | | (瓜3菠) |
| 6. With the above parameters unchanged, modify the weight of ¨lord-hanfugirl-v1- 5.safetensors〃 in ¨Addition-Networks〃 to 0.75. The result is shown in Figure 4. | | 6.瓃把计ぃ跑薄猵盢¨Additiona1-Networks〃い家¨lord-hanfugirl-v1-5.safetensors〃舦э0.75ネΘ挡狦瓜4┮ボ |
| | | |
Dear visitor,you are attempting to view a subscription-based section of lawinfochina.com. If you are already a subscriber, please login to enjoy access to our databases . If you are not a subscriber, please subscribe . Should you have any questions, please contact us at:
+86 (10) 8268-9699 or +86 (10) 8266-8266 (ext. 153)
Mobile: +86 133-1157-0713
Fax: +86 (10) 8266-8268
database@chinalawinfo.com
| |
眤眤瞷璶秈琌猭璣ゅ呼穦盡跋眤琌и璣ゅノめ钡 祅魁秈穦盡跋琩高眤┮惠璶獺眤临ぃ琌и 璣ゅノめ叫猔ユ莱禣ノΘи璣ゅ穦 Τ拜肈叫ㄓ筿玹高
Tel: +86 (10) 82689699, +86 (10) 82668266 ext. 153
Mobile: +86 13311570713
Fax: +86 (10) 82668268
E-mail: database@chinalawinfo.com
|
| | | | | | | | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Message: Please kindly comment on the present translation.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Translations are by lawinfochina.com, and we retain exclusive copyright over content
found on our website except for content we publish as authorized by respective copyright
owners or content that is publicly available from government sources.
Due to differences in language, legal systems, and culture, English translations
of Chinese law are for reference purposes only. Please use the official Chinese-language
versions as the final authority. lawinfochina.com and its staff will not be directly
or indirectly liable for use of materials found on this website.
We welcome your comments and suggestions, which assist us in continuing to improve
the quality of our materials.
|
|
| |
|
|